Home of the Two-Dimensional Insight Maturity Model (2DIMM)
This form is for epistemic critique only. Submissions are published verbatim. We only add a review ID and date received.
Attribution (as published) NamePseudonymAnonymous
Display name (required unless anonymous)
Affiliation (optional)
ORCID / Website (optional)
Confirmation email (optional) If you want a confirmation email, enter your address. Leave empty to stay fully anonymous.
Email
You may contact me if clarification is needed.
I confirm my submission stays within the defined review scope and excludes application/impact/implementation topics.
Domain knowledge (1–5) 12345
Methods / epistemology knowledge (1–5) 12345
Familiarity with adjacent literature (1–5) 12345
Confidence (1–5) 12345
Feedback Block. Please use one block per feedback. This page provides 3 feedback blocks. If you need more, add another feedback form.
Feedback Block 1
Reference in the paper (required)
Type of feedback (required)
Terminology unclearFormal inconsistencyImplicit assumptionLogical leap / missing derivationUnclear boundary / scopeAlternative theoretical frameOther (name it)
If “Other”, name it
3) Observation (descriptive, no evaluation)
4) Precise critique / question
5) Basis / justification
6) Perspective note (optional)
7) Additional notes (optional)
Feedback Block 2
Feedback Block 3